Showing posts with label film review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label film review. Show all posts

Saturday, July 25, 2026

Film conversations: Dhurandhar & Dhurandhar The Revenge



Chapter 1: The movie-going experience

Due to prior horrid experiences related to popcorn prices rivalling real estate rates in Bengaluru, I rarely go to the multiplexes. As some other viewers have pointed out, theatres are still allowing children into an 'A' rated film. These children use the aisles as playgrounds, which is annoying for all. I blame the parents and the multiplex establishment for spoiling the move-going experience for others. But it was worth putting up with these issues for Dhurandhar.


Chapter 2: Why should you watch this film?

When pseudoseculars are trying their best to diss the film, one should deduce that Dhurandhar is an important event not to be missed. The subject matter is of national importance, and a welcome change from the ridiculous dolled-up versions of spy movies that pander to the superstars' chavanni audiences. The theatre that I went to, I am glad to report, was full with people of all age groups - young, middle-aged, elderly - all enjoying and reacting to the drama in a manner that suggested that they were aware of the importance of this film. 


Chapter 3: The plot

Spy infiltrating an enemy camp is not a novel concept, but Dhurandhar is based on a real person, albeit with a few additions/deletions to the story. I believe that the other characters are also based on real people. Dhurandhar is an unabashedly rousing depiction of the hatred and evil machinations that gangs and terrorists are capable of, especially towards India and Hindus. This, in itself, is a refreshing change from the pseudosecular and atheist (read anti-Hindu) drivel that kept us sedated in the 70s, 80s and 90s. 

One can see why the runtime is as long as it is, and one does not feel it as the narrative is so engaging. There is also enough scope for another part to address the back stories of the lead and other characters.


Chapter 4: The acting

This is first-rate throughout. The uncharacteristically restrained performance from Ranveer Singh, the measured approach of Madhavan who has the best one-liners, the brooding menace of Akshaye Khanna, the understated terrorist demeanour of Arjun Rampal, and the over-the-top presence of Sanjay Dutt add to the action-thriller appeal. 

Surprise packages are Gaurav Gera as a senile, serious-faced shopkeeper, a far cry from his 'Nandu' days, and Rakesh Bedi as the chameleon politician; can't believe he is the same Dilruba from Shrimaan Srimati who goes 'Dollll' with a downturned hand. Sara Arjun (whose name, I naively believed, is a composite of Sachin Tendulkar's children's names!) holds her own against the veterans. 

Dhurandhar is a career-defining event for all these actors. 


Chapter 5: The technical details

Again, everything is fantastic. Given the fact that it is unlikely the film was shot in Pakistan (which has expectedly banned the film), the set design looks authentic. The world building is amazing; cinematography, editing and sound add to it. Aditya Dhar is setting new benchmarks, and it is a joy to witness the change in the subject matter of his films from that of his contemporaries; consider Uri, Baramulla and now this. 


Chapter 6: The music

Special mention for the background music and the songs. Shashwat Sachdev is at his best with the song compositions and remakes of old songs. Each track is a banger, which is pleasantly surprising, because in a film of this nature, the drama and action speak for themselves even without songs. I absolutely loved the retro songs enlivening certain key sequences; Rambha ho! (how good Usha Uthup's voice would have sounded even today in a theatre!), Monica O my darling! and Hawa Hawa add a touch of nostalgia. 

Here's my wishlist for the next part: Shaan title songs (both the Usha Uthup and the Asha Bhonsle ones), Aapka kya hoga janab-e-ali from Laawaris, Mehbooba mehbooba from Sholay, and Zubi zubi from Dance Dance. 


Chapter 7: The message

Dhurandhar is a paan-juice spit on the faces of those who try to hide the truth of Pakistan's terrorist identity. We have borne the brunt of being their neighbours for a long time which the world had ignored - until now. Dhurandhar has single-handedly done what no diplomatic effort has managed so far - bring the world's attention to the fact that Pakistan is a terror haven and the epicentre of global terrorism. 

One loses count of the number of attacks perpetrated by nonstate actors from that country, of which only 3 major ones are shown in the film. Finally, the world gets to experience these; full marks to the makers for inserting real conversations from the 26/11 terrorists and their handlers.

The thing is, Pakistan is a paranoid, insecure entity whose insignificance in the larger world order compels it to draw attention through its ultra aggressive actions. As a result, one cannot say where their army ends and terrorism begins. Their agenda is ostensibly Kashmir, but really, it is ghazwa-e-hind. 

I salute all the 'unknown men' who work unsung and unrecognised to keep us safe from such agendas. 


Final chapter: The bloody pseudoseculars!

What the hell do the pseudoseculars of India want? Why are these snakes in the grass - with due respect to the snakes - up in arms each time a pro-India film comes out? What is it that they get from their anti-India, pro-terror stance? Do they want us to roll over and die each time a terror attack occurs? 

Consider these gems:

Anupama Chopra is the critic wife of a producer/director whose criticism is critically reserved for pro-India films. Apparently, she is concerned about the 'inflammatory anti-Pakistan narrative' of Dhurandhar, but is happy with the 'palatable patriotism' of the ludicrous Pathaan. Sure, film criticism is a subjective exercise, but why are her reviews biased against films that narrate our truth? Perhaps she is in need of some anti-inflammatory tablets on her palate to 'get well soon' from her critical state!

I am a major fan of Hrithik Roshan because of his looks, acting and dancing. But when he says things like 'I do not agree with the politics of the film', I have to draw the line, and ask, 'what exactly do you mean by that?' It is what it is. What we have endured over the years has been shown with a lot of reality in this film. So what exactly do you disagree with? All provocations came from them, we only responded to those provocations. Ironic coming from an actor who mouthed lines like 'India-occupied-Pakistan' in Fighter. 

Radhika Apte is apparently unhappy about brining up a child in an atmosphere of violence shown in the film. It's rich coming from an actress whose character was shot in the forehead in the ultraviolent and sexually explicit series, Sacred Games, not to mention a few other violent films she has acted in (try Rakta Charitra, Badlapur and Vikram Vedha, the last of which also starred Hrithik). For the record, the violence does not appear gratuitous in Dhurandhar. If anything, it fits the narrative; it's... apt(e)!

Anything that blows the lid off the radical ideology behind terrorist attacks and religious conversions is dubbed a 'propaganda movie' by people across the borders, and by their pseudosecular stooges here (consider The Kashmir Files and The Kerala Story). By this measure, Schindler's List should be the most propagandist movie ever - against the Nazis!

I hope Dhurandhar 2 continues to be as 'inflammatory', 'political' and 'violent' as the first one, and blows the lid off more evil acts perpetrated against India and Hinduism. 

Dhurandhar gets 10/10 on IMDb from me, and goes straight into my list of movies to watch about India. 


Update (05/04/2026): Dhurandhar The Revenge 

Yes, Dhurandhar The Revenge is as inflammatory, political and violent as the first one, and does blow the lid off more evil acts perpetrated against India and Hinduism by more evil personalities on both sides of the border. 

Technically, it is on par with the first one. As I had suggested, The Revenge completes Ranveer's character's arc and addresses his backstory. The two parts are complementary and can well be released as an edited one film event a la Bahubali, but I do hope that they resist the temptation to milk it by going for another part. 

Songs are a bit of a letdown, and I missed a banger like Shararat in this one. None from my wishlist of retro songs listed above featured in this one, but Tamma Tamma somewhat made up for it, especially when it is played during an action scene involving Sanjay Dutt (on whom the original was picturised; is it the original, though, because remember the controversy regarding Tamma Tamma and Jumma Chumma?). Hum pyar karne wale, I thought, sounded out of place. Oye oye was excitatory, as it was, when Tridev first came out. 

Dhurandhar has drawn the world's attention to another neglected danger. It is beyond comprehension how the rest of the world has thus far ignored the perils of a failed state having nuclear capability, which can at any minute fall into the hands of terrorists with destructive tendencies. Forget terrorists, even their ministers have openly said that they would launch nuclear attacks on India if the ongoing war on Iran spreads to involve Pakistan. 

As expected, pseudoseculars of India have once again crawled out of the woodwork to undermine the film's story and success. The less attention they get, the better it is for the country. As it is, our geopolitical situation is like being stuck between two gutters filled with intrusive venomous creatures that will stop at nothing less than destroying our religion and culture. Remember that there is simply no other country earmarked for us Hindus; either we fight for Bharata, or we keep getting persecuted. 

The two Dhurandhars herald pleasant tidings if you want to see the back of anti-Hindu narratives in mainstream films. Here's to more such films that blow the lid off radical, converting religions and ideologies. 

And yes, honsla eendhan badla to the unknown men and women who are working silently to eliminate anti-India forces. 

Dear Dhurandhars, when you are done on the other side of the border, there is another list for you of those that need your attention on this side of it. 


Picture source: https://www.ottplay.com/features/dhurandhar-review-aditya-dhar-movie-ranveer-singh-akshaye-khanna/107729167b805


Thursday, August 24, 2023

A mainstream threesome

Recently, I have come across at least three mainstream programs wherein the protagonists are gay.  

There are, no doubt, more such programs out there (I am told that there is a host of 'Thai BL' drama out there that I am yet to discover).

But these three are the ones I have seen and liked.  

Here's a list of them, with my take on what they mean for LGBT-inclusivity.

Gameboys: This is a 2020 Filipino web-series wherein the two main characters are male teenagers who discover their own sexual orientation over the course of online games and chats, in the background of the pandemic induced lockdown.  [PS: I could only find Season 1 on Netflix India]  

The diffidence in accepting one's sexuality, and the frequently changing interactions in young relations are well depicted in this series.  There is hardly any interference from the adults in the lives of these young people; in fact, the mother of one of the leads is so understanding and supportive that she should be enshrined as the prototype of an ideal, broadminded parent that every gay adolescent afraid of coming out should be blessed with.  

Good writing, with terrific use of the lockdown restrictions to depict the pining for union between the leads, and the leads themselves who are as charming as they are adept in emoting and expressing these interactions, makes this is an engaging series with a feelgood factor working in its favour.  

With so much going for it, Gameboys makes it easier to accept the boys' relations from the point of view of a viewer who has no idea about gay relations.  

Hi baby! - sorry, couldn't resist that one.  

Heartstopper: Again, male teenagers go through the pangs of discovering their sexuality; only, this 2022 web-series is set in England.  The relationship tangles, interpersonal strife, and parental acceptance/non-acceptance are depicted here in a no-holds-barred manner, which makes this a lot more intense and emotional affair.  Credit, once again, should go to the writing, direction and acting by the entire cast - can't go wrong with Olivia Colman in the scheme of things, can we?

During the course of the two seasons, this series manages to cover issues pertaining to all the letters of LGBT acronym, besides touching upon eating disorders, self-harm, and that other letter in the extended acronym: A - asexuality.  

Red, White & Royal Blue: A trans-Atlantic love affair between two grown men is made all the more sensational by the fact that the leads happen to be a prince and a president's son.  Based on a novel of the same name, this 2023 American film struck an immediate chord with the viewers and generated a huge positive buzz on social media.  What works here is the chemistry between the leads; it helps that they are both incredibly good-looking and act wonderfully well.  

What's also good is that this mainstream film does not shy away from showing the intimate moments between the gay leads.  The romance is so engrossing that one forgets that this is not a star-crossed straight love story, such as Romeo & Juliet or Heer-Ranjha; a staple diet we have feasted on in our heteronormative mainstream film-viewing experience thus far.  

This just goes to show that the heartstrings can be tugged at just as well by well-depicted gay love stories as straight ones.  

***

The larger point that emerges from all these watershed creations is this: LGBT relationships are normal.  They are variants of romantic/sexual relations, and are not in any way inferior to straight relations.  The same process of falling in love, relationship issues, breakups, and reunions that are part of straight relations are also common to LGBT relations.  

After all, one falls in love with an individual, whose personality, worldview, and affability is congruous with oneself.  So, how does it matter if that individual happens to be a man, woman or transsexual?  

I have written in detail about these issues, calling for acceptance of alternative sexuality in an earlier article. 

Now, while I appreciate these three programs for bringing gay relations into the mainstream across the world, I can't help wondering when we, here in India, would be doing our gay community a huge favour by creating similar content.  

If you leave out a few series in the OTT space [as in Made In Heaven 1 & 2 (about the travails of a gay protagonist, with an impressive Arjun Mathur playing the gay man), The Married Woman (lesbian affair of a married woman), and His Story (gay affair of a married man)], all of which, I must add, are excellent creations, there is a woeful lack of meaningful depictions of gayness across all film industries of India.  

On the other hand, gay characters over the years have been shown as mere caricatures, to be made fun of, or to be considered abnormal, or to be discriminated against.  

The nuances explored in the above three landmark productions are patently absent in the Indian context, and one has to wonder why this should be so, when we all know that the Hindi Film Industry has more than its share of gay filmmakers and actors.  It is disappointing that none these filmmakers have thus far taken the lead to address this situation.  Perhaps commercial considerations may be hindrances to producing an out and out gay film?   

This only leads me to appreciate what the makers of some small but effective Bollywood films have achieved in terms of bringing fringe sexual issues to the open.  At least here, the list is impressive: Vicky Donor (about sperm donation), Dum Laga Ke Haisha (obesity in sexual partner), Shubh Mangal Savdhan (erectile dysfunction), Badhaai Ho (late-life pregnancy), Janhit Mein Jaari (woman advocating condom use), Dream Girl (phone erotica), and Pad Man (menstrual hygiene).  

To me, these are much more meaningful than any of those big budget, over-the-top, opium-to-the-masses type of hypermasculine drivel that film industries across the country dole out to pander to the whims of hero-worshipping, sycophantic fans of aged superstars.

Huge shout out also to the makers and actors of a few small LGBT-themed Hindi films: Shubh Mangal Zyada Saavdhan (male gay relations with mainstream actors: Ayushmann Khurrana and Jitendra Kumar - well done you guys), Chandigarh Kare Aashiqui (transsexual relationship with Ayushmann Khurrana and Vaani Kapoor - kudos to Vaani for doing this role), and Badhaai Do (lavender marriage between a male and female gay person with Rajkummar Rao and Bhumi Pednekar - again, well done on breaking stereotypes).

Now, if only the mainstream Bollywood guys could take a cue and put together a big budget musical extravaganza in which the leads are gay or lesbian or trans.  

Imagine gay versions of QSQT, MPK and HAHK with same-sex lovers mouthing lyrics such as So what if we are alone, with you along we can achieve anything - I am yours, since ages; Go go go pigeon, convey my first love letter to my lover; and Mother O Mother, listen to the crow on the roof; your darling has fallen for the love hermit (see what I did there?).

If and when that happens, and if we can, as an audience, watch them without cringing just like the fans of the above three films across the world have done, we would have taken a huge step forward in terms of gender inclusivity and equal opportunities for all representatives of the LGBT community.  

So, would it be too much to ask for a Rocky Aur Raju Ki Prem Kahani?  

Dharma Productions, over to you.  


Pictures sources:

  • https://www.imdb.com/title/tt12508898/
  • https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10638036/
  • https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10172266/

Monday, October 24, 2022

Film conversations: Kantara (2002) & Kantara: A Legend-Chapter 1 (2025)

Kantara is turning out to be a sleeper hit, running chiefly on the fuel of word of mouth.  Very rarely do I venture into a multiplex, but when the family insisted that it was our 'national duty' to watch this film since everyone else was, just as during Dangal, I had to give in.  But of course, my grouse is about the multiplex experience, not the film per se; the film itself is first rate.  

Think of Thithi in terms of the rustic rawness, and you have it in this.  Think of Jallikattu in terms of beautifully lit night scenes in the jungle and background music, and you have them in this.  Think of the eerie jungle mystique of Churuli, and you have that here.  Think of Karnan in terms of the village being under siege and the villagers fighting back against the police/landlord, and you can see the similarity.  

But then Kantara is not confined to any of these descriptions; it stands alone in its own right as a showcase of the culture of Uttara Kannada/Malenadu/Udupi regions of Karnataka, specifically of bhuta kola, or the spirit dance/worship artform.  The situations and dialect is so true to the region, that even Kannada audiences need to read the subtitles sometimes to make sense of the drama, which comes with a smattering of Tulu, the local language.  

Kantara could have ended up like a documentary, but the makers have come up with a clever combination of intrigue, culture, spirituality and humour to keep one engrossed for the two and half hour duration of the film.  I could almost taste the ele-adike (betel leaf & nut) in my mouth as the scenes showing the natural beauty and culture of Kundapura unfolded.  And as touted, the denouement is captivating.  There are sexual innuendos and swear words throughout, which makes it difficult to classify this as a family film.    

The film is not without flaws: it could have lingered on certain moments instead of the breakneck pace we get to see, the change in the landlord's and police officer's characters could have been shown more convincingly, the mother's lament that her son is walking in the footsteps of his father is not explored fully, the entire romantic/sexual angle could have been more implicit or even eliminated, and the background music, though excellent, could have been toned down a bit, but I suspect this is down to the multiplexes jacking up the volume rather than any fault of the makers.  

Kantara goes to show what can be achieved by focusing on our indigenous culture, rather than the standard Bollywood fare that major production houses dish out.  It also demonstrates the stature of regional, especially South Indian, cinema that is growing with every outing.  Not least, this is a successful demonstration of the untapped cinematic potential of our culture, spirituality, smritis, shrutis, puranas, and itihasas, which, if Kantara's success is any indication, we will be thankfully seeing more of.   

The only blemish on Kantara is that one of its songs appears to be more than 'inspired' by another music group's song which is at least five years old.  It would be prudent for Kantara's makers to acknowledge this if they haven't done so, and give due credit to the original song's makers.  

This does not, however, diminish what Kantara otherwise achieves.  In a time when needless remakes of old classics or films from other languages are the norm - not to mention the biopics galore on every conceivable high achiever - Kantara is a rare danta kathe, or a folktale, that is remake-proof: neither is it a remake of anything else, nor can anyone remake it into another language given that it is a product of a specific local culture.  

So, well done to the entire team.  Highly recommended viewing!  



Kantara: A Legend-Chapter 1 - update November 2025


Subtlety is often the casualty at the altar of grandiosity. 

Kantara, unfortunately, has fallen prey to this phenomenon. 

Sadly, the legend has been somewhat superseded by stardom. When rousing music welcomes the hero and he mouths words such as 'did I arrive late?' upon entry - ostensibly to other characters, but really to his doting fans - you should know that stardom and onscreen persona have taken a higher position than the story. 

I believe the brief given to the makers by the producers was to reimagine the first one on a much grander scale. Only, it has ended up becoming louder and needlessly complicated. Bigger does not always mean better, and this one is certainly several notches below the first one. If only they had focused more on the actual bhuta kola tradition and the bhakti aspects. 

The plot appears fully fictitious, as opposed to partially fictitious that the first one was. This one does not add to or explain the story of the first one. 

One scene - the fight upon a disintegrating temple chariot - appears very similar to the wheel-fight scene from one of the Pirates of the Caribbean installments. The setting and plot is somewhat reminiscent of the Kannada classic, Ondanondu Kaladalli, although I must hasten to add that the latter, though dated, is far superior. 

I hope the makers resist the temptation to milk the franchise, or, at the very least, keep it subtler and relevant to the bhuta kola legend. 

Can't stand another pointless adu innondu danta kathe. 


Picture sources: 

  • https://www.deccanherald.com/entertainment/entertainment-news/rishab-i-always-aim-to-reflect-issues-of-society-1147789.html
  • https://www.google.com/search


 

Monday, September 12, 2022

Film conversations: Sakutumba Sametha

After a long time, certainly not since Oggarane, have I come across a Kannada film that conveys what it has to say subtly without any over the top shenanigans.  To be fair, I haven't watched too many films recently to compare this with other similarly paced ones, but I am sure these are few and far in between, given Kannada films' penchant for the bombastic and sometimes crude wordplay.  I must admit, I was sceptical going into this one for these very reasons, but I am happy to report that Sakutumba Sametha is not guilty of any of these irritants.

The Sakutumba team has managed to show that convoluted storylines, toxic masculinity, raunchy item songs, heavy/crude dialogues, crazed facial expressions, enhanced dramatics, positive endings and similar cinematic tropes are not required to create good content.    If anything, Sakutumba subverts these tropes to include nuanced expressions, subtle humour, day to day conversational dialogues, natural acting, and an open ending, to stitch together a compelling and engaging lighthearted comedy drama that Kannada cinema was so badly in need of.  

Sakutumba has the basic premise of marriage at its core, around which situations and relationships are created/explored.  Is it only the bride's family that is desperate to find a match?  Does a man have it easy in terms of finding a match and dictating terms to the bride's family?  Is it always a man's prerogative to accept or reject a marriage proposal?  Should there be a definite reason to cancel a wedding?  What if the groom's side is more accommodating and flexible than the bride's?  Sakutumba tackles these issues bravely to present a realistic modern day picture of marriage and fractious family relationships minus the patriarchal claptrap that marital issues are usually ensconced in.

My only grouses are minor: there are occasional gaps in between dialogues which make them appear stilted, family members start bickering with each other in front of the other family whereas they are likely to be guarded in such situations, and if it had had a more definite ending it would have rounded things off neatly.  But like I said, I am nitpicking; overall this is a rare exercise in subtlety that is suitable for viewing by all, or make that sakutumba sametha!

As a content creator myself, I understand the makers' motivation to create content with passion and quality as driving forces, rather than mass appeal and commercial considerations.  For this reason alone, well done to the entire team, especially the writing/directing team, and Paramvah Studios for backing such a project.  


Image source:
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/kannada/movie-details/sakutumba-sametha/movieshow/81914023.cms

Thursday, July 18, 2019

Film ratings & reviews on IMDb

As I have said, the internet and TV have entered into holy matrimony.

Their union will be a sealed deal as soon as we are able to get rid of money-guzzling satellite dish services.

Already, this (h)App-y marriage has produced many bonny bundles of joy: Netflix India, Amazon Prime, Zee5 and Hotstar, with many more siblings to follow.  

Through these apps I have gone about catching up with some of the finer films that we only get to hear about during award ceremonies, but never actually get to watch.  This is apart from the usual commercial films that we have access to.


Old or new, documentaries or films, genre-based or not, Hindi, English, regional or international languages, they're all included in the watch-list under my profile, gruvy-muvy on IMDb.

Also find my reviews of select films under the same profile.

A rough guide to my ratings on the database goes like this:

Stars (out of 10)
My reaction
5 or below
What’s all the hype about this one?
6-9
This is worth seeing
Perfect 10
You’re nuts for missing this!

A list of films/documentaries/shorts that are relevant to understanding the following topics can be found here:







Sunday, June 9, 2019

Indian cinema arrives

As I have often surmised, the marriage between Internet and TV has almost been solemnized and the two have already given us many babies: apps that give us access to quality international, national and regional content.  

What a relief from TV's old affliction: K-serials! 

From among the few that I have seen recently on these apps, two offerings from Indian cinema are setting the tone for others to emulate: Tumbbad (2018) and Sonchiriya (2019).


Tumbbad is all red and fiery; a superior take on mythology and greed set in an obscure rainy Maharashtrian village.  The locations, cinematography, story, acting, music, production values are all first rate.  It even has a moral that it delivers without being preachy.  Background score by Jesper Kyd and Ajay-Atul's music are exceptional, especially the title track.

Sonchiriya, a sordid tale of betrayal and tragedy among dacoits in the ravines of Chambal is gritty and hard-hitting.  All the cinematic virtues I have listed under Tumbbad are applicable to Sonchiriya too.  

I have to also make a special mention of Badhai Ho for taking up an unusual subject such as late-life pregnancy, and delivering it well.  It's easily the best of mainstream Hindi films in 2018.  Terrific performances by the supporting cast: Neena Gupta and Gajraj Rao.  Surekha Sikri outshines everyone (she deservedly got the Best Supporting National Award, 2019).

On the other end of the scale, there was that expensive turkey which I was unfortunately dragged in to watch in a multiplex, shelling out hard-earned but easily-wasted money: Zero.  

Had I had my way, that's exactly the amount and time I would have spent on this thought-disordered fantasy that neither entertains nor delivers any message.  

Sample this: a wheelchair bound genius cerebral palsy afflicted scientist (which in itself is an unrealistic take on Stephen Hawking since CP is associated with mental retardation), rides her wheelchair in a red wedding sari on American roads to meet her dwarf ex-boyfriend who has just won a ticket to Mars aboard a misspelt NASA rocket.  Enough said!  Zero is easily the worst film of 2018.  Can't believe they spent 200 crores on this drivel.

So, what sets apart good Indian cinema from bad?  There is no secret sauce that works all the time, but comparing the above films, I could glean the following:
  • the will and vision to execute collaborative efforts bringing together great professionals across all areas of film-making, regardless of the box-office outcome of these ventures
  • painstaking pre- and post-production work, such as script, story, screenplay, locations, production values (post-prod work in Tumbbad apparently took > 2 years)
  • authenticity of story-lines and settings: Indian culture/society depicted with realism; not the usual pseudo-western take on urban India
  • both Tumbbad and Sonchiriya DO NOT have egoistic super/hyper-stars with legions of blind fans nor any undeserving star-kids who need to be showcased to the world over and above the supporting cast and script 
  • both revel in quality film-making undertaken for the sheer pleasure of the craft
And it shows. 

Mainstream filmmakers, watch Tumbbad.  This is how all Indian cinema should be made...








Image sources:
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=58398243
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=58034304

Monday, June 5, 2017

Film conversations: Bahubali - inspired by the epics?


Here's the question that was bothering the collective consciousness of the entire nation for the last two years: Why did Kattappa kill Baahubali?  Now we know.

But here's what rankles: surely a character like Sivagami who is an astute Rajmatha, and is also aware of the hatred Bijjaladeva has for Baahubali, would have thoroughly investigated matters before ordering Kattappa to kill Baahubali.  Here's one probable reason for this: Baahubali 2 has a lot of ground to cover in terms of plot development, which makes her decision seem hurried.    

While Baahubali: The Beginning was about setting the tone and raising the intrigue in the minds of the audience, Baahubali: The Conclusion is all about recounting the events with a rather rapid culmination of the story.  

As with other films, the first part appears a better film than the second one because of those twin reasons: the freshness of the first outing, and the fact that the second part does not live up to the enhanced audience expectations after the rousing first part.

It's not that the Conclusion does not try: it throws everything in the book into the narrative to keep you enthralled.  As a result it does appear to be cramming in a bit more than it should; as opposed to the Beginning that was a right combination of measured approach and jaw dropping action.  The tribal war scene from the Beginning, to me, beats the climax of the Conclusion any day.  

Having said that, overall the two films are an awesome exhibition of filmmaking, reflecting the story writer's and director's (who happen to be father-son duo, respectively) grand cinematic visions.  Well done to the entire team for creating a pan-Indian phenomenon, and for putting an Indian film on the global platform, without any significant involvement of the Hindi Film Industry.

But here's what's very intriguing for me, personally: the epic story seems to have been inspired by the two original epics of India: Ramayana and Mahabharata; especially the latter.  Here's how:

Baahubali is Bhima/Arjuna-like figure with a combination of power and heroism, and his antagonist Bhallaladeva makes for a fine venom spewing Duryodhana.  The latter's father, Bijjaladeva is at once the embittered Dhritarashtra as the older brother who was deprived of the right to rule due to his deformity, as well as the evil schemer, Shakuni who plots the downfall of Baahubali.  

Devasena's character too appears to be inspired by the stories of two women: Draupadi who is insulted in a court full of people, and the captive Sita who is kept against her will in the Ashoka Vatika while she awaits her redemption.  Kattappa is the Bhishma who is bound by honour to serve the kingdom and is therefore forced to do certain things against his will.

Even some of the events fit in with the stories from the epics.  Take for instance the sequence in the Conclusion where Baahubali, who is living incognito, rides with the coward prince on a wild boar hunting ride and inspires him to take affirmative action when faced with danger.  

This is so very like Arjuna as Brihannala inspiring the timid Uttara Kumara when faced with the Kaurava army (even the character in the Conclusion is called Kumara).  Then there is also the cattle reference: the go-harana episode in the Mahabharata at the end of agnyatavasa, appears to have been adapted as the stampede of the cattle with their horns on fire in the same subplot.

This is not a complaint; just an observation.

The makers leave a couple of doors open towards the end of Conclusion: Bijjaladeva is not killed, which raises the possibility of him scheming again; and there is a child's voice that asks (during the end credits) whether Mahendra Baahubali's son becomes the next king to which an elderly man's voice tantalizingly replies, 'who know's what's in Shiva's mind?'

I sincerely hope there are no plans for a third outing.  Baahubali 1 was the beginning, and 2 the conclusion, as clearly mentioned in the titles.  Together they tell one killer of a story, and contain some of the most memorable characters ever: Kattappa and Baahubali have entered the echelons of other iconic characters of Indian cinema such as Gabbar Singh and Mogambo.  And there they should remain.  

One hopes that their creators are not tempted into milking the story and stretching it into another never-ending, meaningless franchise.

On the other hand, it would be great if they move on to depict the epics that seem to have inspired Baahubali: Ramayana and Mahabharata, with the same awe inspiring grand cinematic vision and fervour.  

Let's hope they do.



Image source: http://static.spotboye.com/images/bollywood/news/1489643419927/baahubali-2-to-answer-the-questions-of-baahubali-1.jpg









  


Wednesday, December 14, 2016

Film conversations: Kahaani 2


While the first Kahaani was advertised as 'a mother of a story' (and it was; kahaani = story), the second one alludes to a different kind of motherhood.  

The grittiness, realism, Kolkata, Bengali culture and accent, the lead actress, the director and the mystery element, all return in Kahaani 2, minus the other support cast from the first installment.  

Nevertheless, some parallels are worth noting between 1 and 2: the ironic killer LIC agent from 1 is replaced by a killer female police officer; the abetting Bengali police officer is replaced by another non-Bengali police officer who also happens to be the main protagonist's ex-husband; and the doubting senior non-Bengali detective is replaced by another doubting Bengali police officer.  Also present is the nondescript love interest of the main protagonist who has nothing much to do; and of course the mystery element from 1 that keeps you guessing throughout.

In all this, the film manages to make a serious point on child sexual abuse.  The dubious culprit who is also the uncle of the child, the denying grandmother who invariably takes her son's side and blames the child for all things wrong, the attempts to cover-up - they are all there; and for most parts the makers manage to get the issues right.

But the issue is used only to add to the thriller aspect of the narrative, rather than to make a social point, as in Monsoon Wedding.  Nevertheless, the grimness of this subject is matched amply by the bleakness of the backdrop and the deglamourised look sported by the lead protagonist.  

Comparisons are no doubt, odious; but since this has been presented as Kahaani 2, one cannot help pit it against the first Kahaani.  It is also true that sequels rarely ever steal a march over the first one, and this is no different.  

Even though the tautness is there, it is no way as riveting or unpredictable as the first one.  The sting in the tail certainly is not as surprising as the previous one.  If anything, the fast pace and editing, which are probably meant to keep the story taut and interesting, take away the real feel of the lead character's personality, along with the reason behind why she is initially a recluse, and how she transforms herself into a protective mother, later.  

A few loose threads hang about; for instance, why did the policeman - far too handsome to belong in a dilapidated small town police station - who was hand-in-glove with the mother all along, allow her to face the deadly duo all on her own towards the end?  The mother, after having been declared 'officially dead', manages to emigrate to the US for the child's treatment, with only a changed name on her passport.  

In spite of all this, I would go miles to see a quality film, as opposed to ego-inflated-superstar-oriented, ostentatious, self-glorifying, kahaani-less films.   

Therefore, I highly recommend Kahaani 2, which is well worth your time and money, and will not disappoint you, on the whole. 


Image source: http://media3.bollywoodhungama.in/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Kahaani-2-3-306x393.jpg

Saturday, May 28, 2016

Film conversations: The Angry Birds Movie


Okay, we all know what this is about.  Almost all of us has pulled the slingshot with an angry bird in it to target the pigs and their precarious skyscrapers.  

Therefore it is but obvious that one should be curious to find out just what got the birds so fired up.  

Why did these flightless birds get their knickers in a twist - in a manner of speaking, because they don't wear any!  

What are the green pigs after?  

What is the reason for the angry birds to hurl themselves as slingshots at the pigs' empire?  

What brings about this transformation from egg-rearing to self-hurling in the inhabitants of the peaceful bird island? 

If you - like millions of bird sympathizers - have always been troubled by these birdy existential questions, then you will find your answers in this movie.

I am not going to play spoilsport and reveal the plot fully.  Here it is, in an eggshell...err nutshell.  

The red, yellow and black birds meet each other - where else, in an anger management class!  

Of course they never get over their angry selves, which is just as well, because they are called upon to channelize their anger towards the egg-stealing pigs.  

This is also the story of the hero of the franchise - Red, the one with the bushy eyebrows - who evolves from being the most hated bird on the island to the most adored one.  

Now about the picturization.  It is, overall, very satisfactory.  

The birds, pigs, the island, the pigs' ship, and their wobbly castles have all been endearingly recreated, reminiscent of the game itself.  

The baby birdies are of course, high on the cuteness factor, and the pigs - who first appear midway through the film - received whistles from the audience even though they are the villains of the piece. 

But the maximum applause is reserved for the slingshot sequence; which is but natural, for that was the reason we had fallen in love with the game version in the first place.  

The sequences are shown from both ends of the slingshot - perhaps to enhance the 3-D effect; and even though the birds hit a few castles, we don't get to see the castles crumbling down upon each other as much as we like to.  

If only there was a side-on view showing the birds being hurled in a trajectory and the turrets falling down, just as in the game version!  That would have had the audience hurling popcorn at each other in the seats!

That apart, it is fun time throughout.  

I asked my daughter what she liked about the movie.  Her answer - considering her pillow cover is Angry Birds themed - was unambiguous: 'EVERYTHING!'



Image source: https://m.media-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BMTY3MjU0NDA0OF5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTgwNTc0MTU3OTE@._V1_.jpg

Thursday, November 12, 2015

Film conversations: Prem Ratan Dhan Payo


There are a couple of things to bear in mind when you go to watch a Sooraj Barjatya film.

(A) Suspend disbelief, and (B) Never go by critics' reviews.

'A' because a few liberties are always taken in his films, especially when it comes to the medical field.  You just have to accept what's being presented, let go, and enjoy!  That's the best way to watch his films.

'B' because the last time the critics panned his film, it went on to become Indian cinema's biggest ever hit: Hum Aapke Hain Kaun..!  


So what's Prem Ratan Dhan Payo all about?  

I won't give away the story, but you may get a general idea about what it might be about. 

So here goes.

Remember Chitchor?  That simple yet touching film made by the same Rajshri Productions, with unforgettable songs by Ravindra Jain and Yesudas?  Stellar performances by Amol Palekar, Zareena Wahab, A K Hangal, Dina Pathak, Vijayendra Ghatge and that cute child actor Raju Shreshtha?  Yes, that one.

Take that.

Also, while you are at it, grab Paheli (incidentally Amol Palekar who acted in Chitchor, directed Paheli).

Also add a dash of Mark Twain's Prince and the Pauper.  

And don't forget to sprinkle a bit of Ram aur Shyam, Seeta aur Geeta, Chaalbaaz and Kishen Kanhaiya. 

Oh, and for the title, replace Ram with Prem in Meera Bai's bhajan, Ram Ratan Dhan Payo.  

And there you have it.  Prem Ratan Dhan Payo.

Okay, I am being a tad unfair.  Yes, PRDP reminds one of all the films mentioned above, yet it is different.  

For starters, is made on a much larger, grandiose scale.  There are subplots woven into the story.  Barjatya has made all efforts to present the story in a novel, light hearted manner.    And it works.


So what's the same?

As with any Barjatya film, PRDP, at its core, is about love.  It displays Indian tradition and draws its emotional appeal heavily from family values and relationships within the family.  It is opulent.  The sets are lavishly mounted, and it is a visual treat.  


And what's different?

First of all, PRDP does not have a massive starcast, as in HAHK.  There's only Anupam Kher.  Reema Lagoo and Alok Nath are conspicuously absent!  

There are less songs than a typical Barjatya film.  

And - get this - there is action!  There is a stunningly crafted horse-coach scene in the beginning, sword fight in the middle, and dishum-dishum at the end.  Far too much action for a Barjatya film!  


A few grouses

The background music was a bit too loud, making it difficult to follow the dialogues.  Some songs have been cut to trim down the overall length of the film (it is now 174 minutes long).  

Does it recreate the magic of HAHK?  No.  But then, I don't think any film can.   

  
What works?

Barjatya has got starpower with him, as usual.  That alone will ensure the opening.  Prem has become a saleable commodity, which is sure to draw in his fans by the lakhs.  

The music, songs and choreography are first rate, and it seems that Himesh Reshammiya has a hit on his hands, especially with the title song. 

Overall, terrific Diwali entertainment.  Enjoy it!


Image source: http://s2.dmcdn.net/Ogfwe/1280x720-vd5.jpg

Sunday, September 13, 2015

Film conversations: Phantom


His previous film made millions, but this one will clearly not.  Director Kabir Khan's film on 26/11 will get nowhere near the collections of his previous 'feelgood' film.  Because they don't like it you see.  By they I mean not just our 'friendly' neighbours, but also their expatriates who live in other countries, and their co-brothers.  These days you need to entice them with friendly themes to ensure that you have a hit on your hands; as most Hindi film makers seem to be doing recently.  

It would be tough to entice them into watching this one.  Because you see, it tells the truth.  And truth, has always been a bitter pill to swallow for our neighbours.  Their basic policy with regards to 26/11, and all the hundreds of other attacks launched against our land from their soil can be summarized in just two words: deny and defend.  

Deny they had any hand in whatever happened, and deny that the terrorists were their own kith and kin.  If confronted with the truth, defend yourself to the core; never give an inch; because attack is the best form of defence.  

And this does not just pertain to the government officials or spy agencies; it applies to almost all citizens of that country.  Which is why a ban on the film was readily accepted by all concerned.  

Some Indian, who dares to enter their soil to kill their own men!  How can this be allowed?  Only America is allowed to do that.

Now about the film.  It is well made throughout.  Even though there is a disclaimer at the beginning of the film to state that the story is not based on any actual character, it is obvious from the amazing likeness of the actors to the real life culprits, as to who this is based on.  Especially the actor playing David Headley; the resemblance is uncanny.  Besides, what are we scared of?  It is based on 26/11, and the terrorists who plotted the attack, period.   

Acting by all is good, but Mohammed Zeeshan Ayyub steals the show from right under the noses of Saif Ali Khan and Katrina Kaif.  He is just sensational in a small but significant role.  One can see his stock rising in the days to come, and he richly deserves it.  

If anything, the film is probably a bit too slick, and I wonder if a more measured approach would have worked better.  Especially the manner in which Daniyal (Khan's character) is cajoled into taking up the assignment is a bit too abrupt.  Also - I know others might disagree - but nobody on our side should have died in the end.  It should have been a clean, clinical mission that achieves its goal of eliminating the terrorists behind 26/11, without any loss on our side.  Haven't we lost enough already?

I am not going to give away anymore of the plot-line.  Like Baby, we want people to watch this film and find out for themselves what could be achieved with a little bit of derring-do.  

Yes, it is a story we wish were true.  And director Kabir Khan and the others behind the film deserve rich accolades for telling it.

It is still possible to put this idea into action.  We do have the personnel who are capable of undertaking such a mission.  But, is the government listening?



Image source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/7/71/Phantom_Hindi_Poster.jpg


Sunday, April 5, 2015

Film conversations: Baby


Just watched Baby.  Neeraj Pandey, who gave us the exquisite A Wednesday, revisits the terrorist theme in this fast moving action film.  

Very rarely do we get espionage genre right in Hindi films, but it appears that Pandey is on the right track with this one.  Baby is a refreshingly gutsy effort that says it as it is, without mincing words.  One hears that a sequel to Baby is being planned, which can only be good news.

I do not want to go into the specific details of the plot, because I would like to encourage those who have not yet watched this film to watch it.  Anybody who is interested in the secularism and unity of India should watch this film.  Yes, it has got Muslim terrorists, yes they come from Pakistan, but it is not about mindless bashing of either of these religious/national groups.  

There are some characters who are Muslims who help break the terrorist nexus, in addition to Pakistani actors who also feature in the star-cast.  Mostly, judging by the messages left on the film website message boards, it seems that people have realised that this film is about terrorism, and not about hating any particular community or country.  In fact Baby does not take sides, or justify the actions of any group; it cuts straight to the chase.  At least, it does not indulge in partial religious bashing the way PK did.

But as always there are those who take exception.  The Pakistani government banned it.  The film has not done well in those circuits where expatriate Pakistanis live - such as in some parts of the UK.  Just compare the earnings of Baby in the UK (Rs 1.24 crore) with PK (21.63 crore) or Kick (13.2 crore), and you will see what I mean*.  

Leave aside foreign circuits.  It is a travesty that this film struggled to reach 100 crores in our own market (it eventually stopped at 95.56 crore).  It is ridiculous that we do not seem to value movies made with substance and a message.  It seems our audience is very much in love with superstars-led, nepotism-filled brainless entertainment, running around trees, and item songs.  

How else can you explain the huge success of a crass and ludicrous film such as Happy New Year?

Looking forward to the Baby sequel.


*[source: bollywoodhungama.com]
Image source: http://st1.bollywoodlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/baby-2508141.jpg

Saturday, March 28, 2015

Film conversations: Cinderella (2015)

Okay, this one I watched because of my daughter.  The exams were over, and we were out in the mall. There was a 10 O'clock show in the multiplex; we made an impulsive decision to see the film.  

And we were not disappointed.  Going with low expectations - the same old story; been there done that kind of a feeling - might have helped, because we came out thoroughly entertained.  My daughter, of course, sat riveted.

Actor/director, Kenneth Branagh does a sterling job of making this story an interesting one, with a few clever deviations from the original.  In this story, Cinderella - or Ella as she is first called - sees her mother die after giving her a message: have courage and show kindness.  Her father remarries and subsequently dies during one of his travels, leaving Ella with the evil stepmother and her two daughters.  
The gradual deterioration of Ella's status in her own house is well depicted, and we learn that it is actually her stepsisters who come up with the name Cinderella, after they see Ella's face blackened with cinder from all the cooking that she does.  Her attic friends are all mice, and the birds only come towards the end.  

Unlike the original, Cinderella meets the prince during a horse riding session, although she does not know his identity.  The king dies before the prince marries Cinderella, and the prince himself unravels the plot hatched by the stepmother and the grand duke to prevent him from seeing Cinderella again.  The stepmother smashes the glass shoe on the wall, instead of tripping the footman carrying the shoe.  However these deviations - apart from the fast pace of the narrative - add charm to the story and keep one glued to it.


Although she lacks the comic book Cinderella look, Lily James displays the affected yet restrained look of the character very well.  Richard Madden is charming as the prince, as is his father the king, played by Derek Jacobi.  Cate Blanchett, a seasoned actress that she is, brings a level of sophistication and controlled cruelty to her role as the stepmother.  The bungling sisters, Drizella and Anastasia are hilarious, while Stellan Skarsgard is suitably villainous as the grand duke.  Ben Chaplin plays Cinderella's father, and Nonso Anozie is the good captain.   

Helena Bonham Carter continues her streak of playing oddball characters with her role of an atypical fairy godmother - or 'hairy godfather' as she puts it.  The setting up of the carriage and its subsequent disintegration into a pumpkin, mice, lizards and a goose, is a treat to watch.

Overall, a highly enjoyable fare.  Watch it with the whole family.




Image sources:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/c/c2/Cinderella_2015_official_poster.jpg
http://www.hellomagazine.com/imagenes/film/2014120322267/cinderella-posters-lily-james-richard-madden/0-117-196/cinderella-2--z.jpg

Thursday, March 12, 2015

Film conversations: Oggy and the Cockroaches: The Movie


Okay, enough of the serious stuff that I have been writing on in the last few posts.  Let's talk about our animated heroes and their antics.

My daughter, who is well informed about these issues, thanks to her hours of dedicated TV gazing, informed me that the Oggy film was being premiered on TV (here in India)!  Apparently the film, originally called Oggy et les Cafards, Le Film, was released in 2013.  Having discovered the joys of watching Oggy and his friends over the years, I decided to join my daughter, as Oggy, Jack, Bob and the cockroaches took us through four short stories in their movie début.  


The first story is set in the pre-historic days, when Oggy and the roaches evolved through single celled organisms.  The battle between good and evil; between black and white - although sometimes it is just between grey and grey - begins very early, even when our heroes are in a single celled state!  Oggy's uncle, the fireman, orders Oggy to go to the volcano to fetch a pail of... well, fire.

Jack goes along with him, and so do the roaches, just to trouble him and steal his fire.  However, they end up falling inside the volcano, and find that there is another world there.  The hostile region is ruled by that troubled dog, Bob.  His henchmen try to capture the cat brothers to eat them, but they are helped by Olivia, who also teaches them to make fire by rubbing stones.  It is a happy ending when the fire bearing brothers make it back to their domain with Olivia.


The second story is about Oggy trying to rescue the princess Olivia from a castle where she is held captive by the roaches.  But, our blue French feline is a bit of a sissy this time!  He is into embroidery, much to the utter disdain of his father, the king, who wants him to be a brave warrior!  Nevertheless, helped by the animals who are with Olivia - just as they were with Cinderella and Snow White - and his brother, Jack, Oggy manages to rescue the princess.

We move ahead by several eras now.  The third tale is set in London, where the queen is celebrating the birth of a new century.  Jack, this time is Sherlock Holmes, and Oggy, Dr Watson!  Olivia, the troubled damsel, visits them at Baker Street (shouldn't that be Meow Street?), and asks them to retrieve the missing key and bomb.  Once again, the roaches are the culprits, and after much fighting inside the Big Ben, the feline detectives prevail.  But they cannot stop the clock from falling on the queen, who strangely selects the spot directly below the Big Ben for her party!  She should have known better!


In the final story, we are in the future.  This means it is Star Wars time, and Bob, who has an ambition of world domination, deploys the roaches to wreak havoc.  Our French jedi draw out their neon laser swords, while Oggy goes for the... what else, the laser roach swatter!  


Once again, like the TV series, our viewing experience is enhanced by the Indian treatment given to the French goings on.  The voices of Shah Rukh Khan, Sunny Deol, Nana Patekar, Prem Chopra and Shakti Kapoor further animate the characters!  The hilarious dumb ass looks of the characters, superb animation by the French creators, and the inspired Hindi film voice makeovers work like magic together.

It is great fun to watch and listen to Oggy's 'nahin chodoonga...!', Jack's 'Oi Oggy, mere bhai...', the voice over's 'achcha hai...', or, my favourite, Bob's 'thakk thikk...'.

Highly enjoyable movie.  Go for it with the full family.

Thakk thikk... sorry, just felt like saying that again!




Reference:
Oggy and the Cockroaches: The Movie, Director: Olivier Jean-Marie, Xilam & France 3 Cinema 2013

Image sources:
http://ex.inquirer.net/files/2013/09/oggy_moviet.jpg
https://i.ytimg.com/vi/GS_pwSJ8bk0/maxresdefault.jpg
https://scontent.fblr2-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/10391051_789945794399317_6156312725361660463_n.jpg?_nc_cat=104&_nc_sid=6e5ad9&_nc_ohc=HM_oLHXnPZ8AX-MR7iW&_nc_ht=scontent.fblr2-1.fna&oh=531b9de7f3363c780990e25d3128b008&oe=5F28B8AD
http://img4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130608083453/oggyandthecockroaches/images/0/0c/390955_505362629518433_605672566_n.jpg
htts://i2.wp.com/www.cgmeetup.net/home/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/OGGY-and-The-COCKROACHES-Movie-5.jpg?resize=960%2C519

Film conversations: Dhurandhar & Dhurandhar The Revenge

Chapter 1: The movie-going experience Due to prior horrid experiences related to  popcorn prices rivalling real estate rates in Bengaluru, ...